The independent auto dealership industry is in flux. While Buy-Here-Pay-Here (BHPH) dealerships are thriving and subprime dealerships are holding steady, many traditional retail dealers, particularly those selling vehicles above $15,000, struggle to maintain profitability. This shift stems from changing consumer behavior, economic pressures, and increased competition. However, dealerships that understand these challenges and take proactive steps to adapt can still find success in a competitive market.
Who’s Winning and Who’s Struggling?
BHPH Boom and Subprime Stability
BHPH dealerships are outpacing growth expectations, fueled by their ability to provide flexible in-house financing to credit-challenged buyers. In a time when interest rates remain high, and credit approval is tightening, BHPH dealers offer solutions that traditional lenders often cannot. Experian Automotive reports that subprime auto loans accounted for 19.2% of all vehicle financing in Q4 2024, demonstrating that this segment remains stable but is not expanding at the same rate as BHPH.
Retail Dealers Face Headwinds
Conversely, traditional retail dealers, especially those focusing on vehicles above $15,000, are seeing declining sales. Meanwhile, dealers specializing in vehicles under $15,000 are thriving as affordability becomes the primary concern for car buyers. Kelley Blue Book's 2025 Used Car Market Report found that the average used car price remains over $26,000, making affordability a growing issue for budget-conscious buyers.
What’s Driving Retail Dealer Struggles?
1. Economic Pressures: High Costs and Stagnant Wages
Interest Rates & Inflation: With average auto loan rates above 8% for used cars (source: Experian), financing a higher-priced vehicle is increasingly unappealing to budget-conscious buyers.
Wage Stagnation vs. Rising Car Prices: Vehicle prices have risen, but average wages have not kept pace, squeezing middle-class consumers.
2. Consumer Shifts: Affordability Over Premium Features
Shoppers Prioritize Budget-Friendly Options: Many consumers now view cars over $15,000 as luxury purchases, opting for reliable and affordable vehicles instead.
BHPH and Subprime Dealers Offer Easier Paths to Ownership: These dealerships eliminate traditional financing barriers, making them more attractive to many buyers.
Carvana, Vroom, and Facebook Marketplace have revolutionized price transparency, making it difficult for local dealers to compete.
Franchise Dealers use manufacturer-backed certified pre-owned (CPO) programs and special financing incentives to attract higher-income buyers, leaving independent retail dealers struggling to match these offerings.
Financing Barriers: Many independent dealers lack lender relationships to provide competitive financing on higher-priced vehicles.
Strategies for Retail Dealers to Adapt & Thrive
For dealerships looking to turn the tide, the solution isn’t just cutting prices—it’s about adapting marketing, financing, and inventory strategies to meet today’s consumer demands.
1. Enhance Financing Options
Expand Lender Partnerships: Working with multiple financing partners can help secure better buyer rates and terms.
Offer Creative Financing Solutions: Promote low down payments, extended loan terms, and deferred payment options to make higher-priced vehicles more attractive.
2. Optimize Inventory for Market Demands
Data-Driven Buying: Use market data to stock vehicles aligned with local demand. Cars that move well in one metro area might struggle in another—retail dealers must be flexible.
Diversify Pricing: Maintaining a mix of vehicles under $15,000 can help attract a broader customer base.
3. Shift Marketing Messaging to Focus on Value
Emphasize Reliability & Long-Term Savings: Consumers may hesitate to pay more upfront, but dealers can educate them on the benefits of better fuel economy, lower maintenance costs, and warranties on higher-priced vehicles.
Create Localized Campaigns: Geo-targeting and local SEO can help retail dealers compete against national online retailers.
4. Strengthen Online Presence & Digital Marketing
High-Quality Listings Matter: Professional photos and video walkarounds significantly boost online engagement.
SEO & Retargeting Ads: Dealers must optimize their website content and retarget lost visitors with display and social media ads.
Digital Financing Tools: Enabling pre-qualifications and online payment calculators can streamline the buying process.
5. Build Consumer Trust Through Transparency
Vehicle History Reports: Offering free CARFAX or AutoCheck reports builds confidence.
Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) Programs: Even independent dealers can create their own CPO program to increase perceived value.
Customer Reviews & Testimonials: To reinforce credibility, positive experiences must be highlighted on Google, Facebook, and Yelp.
6. Diversify Revenue Streams
Trade-In Incentives: Encouraging aggressive trade-in offers can lower the effective price for buyers.
Add-On Services: Promoting extended warranties and service plans can boost revenue and ease customer concerns about future costs.
7. Train Dealerships to Evolve
Host Webinars & Workshops: Educate sales teams on trending financing solutions and effective digital marketing strategies.
Provide Dealer Playbooks: Offer resources with pricing strategies, sales best practices, and competitive market analysis.
8. Introduce Hybrid Business Models
Adopt BHPH Elements: Retail dealerships can integrate in-house financing options to attract subprime buyers.
Time-Sensitive Promotions: Running limited-time discounts on higher-priced vehicles can help generate urgency.
A Market That Rewards Adaptation
The auto retail market is shifting, but dealerships that adapt their strategies will remain profitable. Traditional retail dealers must reframe their approach by embracing:
Flexible financing to address affordability concerns
Inventory diversification to match changing consumer preferences
A value-driven marketing strategy that highlights reliability over price
A robust digital presence to compete with online disruptors
By implementing these strategies, independent dealerships can overcome market challenges and position themselves for long-term success—even in an era where affordability is king.
Life doesn’t get easier or more forgiving; we become stronger and more resilient. Fueled by this great message, we push ourselves to overcome challenges and become our best selves. Learn how you can too!
The Fastest Growing Dealer Hosting & Listing of Vehicle Feeds
Best Used Cars is Exploding – 15,000+ Vehicles & 257+ Dealer Locations
Best Used Cars is rapidly becoming the go-to platform for independent auto dealers. We now feature over 15,000 vehicles from 257+ dealer locations—and the number is growing daily! Our mission is simple: help dealers own their vehicle feed, control their inventory, and sell more cars.
With fresh overlay themes added monthly, seamless integration across Google, Meta, and TikTok, and new innovations on the horizon, we're giving dealers the tools they need to dominate digital marketing. Whether you’re looking to increase exposure, drive leads, or improve ad performance, Best Used Cars delivers.
Join the movement today and take control of your vehicle feed
Flexible financing to address affordability concerns
